Dune: Part Two
Summary
As someone who take and loved the book as a teenager , see the first of Denis Villeneuve’sDunemovies was a stirring experience . Part 1is satisfy with what I ’d call " legwork " - much of the dialog and shot selection aims to teach the consultation about this skill - fable earth . It presents us with supreme craftsmanship and pose a solid foundation , but , narratively , it ’s mostly a promise . I revalue the world - building on its own terminal figure , but I was most transport by what the vision on display mean for what I already knew was to make out .
sand dune : Part 2is a rich work in just about every way . With the political chess board ground and the optical spoken communication familiar , introducing young information is now much easier . Villeneuve can focus all his attention on immersing us in both the idea of the history and the spectacle of its telling . But despite it being everything I ’d hop for , I could n’t shake the feeling that something was missing at the emotional level . The narrative and aesthetics reach heights that the drama ca n’t quite match .
This , I contend , is baked into the filmmakers ' overture to conform this material . In transforming a story for a new medium , adapters inevitably create problems to work out ; with their two - part approach shot , Villeneuve and his co - writer Jon Spaihts and ( onPart 1only ) Eric Roth tackle many of these elegantly . But as much asPart 2is freed up by the exposition condensed intoPart 1 , it face a critical challenge : the absence seizure of Duke Leto Atreides . The pic tries to fill his void , and comes close . But , with a comparatively small adaptation , I consider it could ’ve come after .
Confining Duke Leto (& Oscar Isaac) To Dune: Part 1 Has Big Consequences
The public ofDuneis one of connive and violence - it is , after all , a story about the evil of power . But amid the brutal Harkonnens , manipulative Bene Gesserit , and desert - hardened Fremen , Duke Leto Atreides stand out . While part of the imperial organisation , he is somehow in person uncorrupted by his station . As the Emperor says inPart 2 , Leto believes in the rules of the heart ; love and pureness are his elementary motivators .
He is perhaps the only graphic symbol inDune : Part 1who would not force a destiny onto Paul if he did not require it . He sacrifices a reaper ’s worth of spicery to hold launch the biography of the mass onboard . His first thought as he feels the political vice closure on him are the trade protection of his son and regret at not having marry Jessica , the woman he love . Oscar Isaac , absolutely plaster bandage , bring him with a zippy soul ; he seems capable to create his own soberness , and his scenes warp to set him at the center .
For his nobleness , the powers that be stigma Leto for expiry . Villeneuve ’s film understands his importance as a tragical zep . The Atreides may be matador , but an edit in the Duke ’s final mo suggests he is actually the bull : dangerous , but easily blinded . The Emperor flap duty in front of him , and he charges , only to be stabbed in the back . Through Isaac ’s portrayal , he isDune ’s most human presence . Leto ’s loss , in both movie and Scripture , is keenly felt .
Custom image by Simone Ashmoore
InDune : Part 2 , he attend over Paul ’s arc like a spectre . When Paul laments that fear is one of the few tools at his disposition in his rise to power , we remember how his Father-God inspired love life in his peers and subjects . And genuine lovemaking at that - far from the religious devotion Paul will receive from the Fremen . Lady Jessica notes that Leto did not believe in revenge . Paul does , and seeks it in his father ’s name . The Duke ’s humanity deepens the heartbreak of Paul ’s turn toward what he larn is his Harkonnen side .
Narratively , thematically , we know these things . But part of what makes cinema great is that film maker get to progress an emotional journey for us to live across one unplowed block of time . Leto exists in part to be an emotional counterpoint to what Paul will become , and if tell in one cohesive narration , we wouldfeelthe agonist ’s sudden embrace of the Lisan al Gaib prophecy much more intensely .
Chani Is An Imperfect Replacement For Dune 2’s Missing Piece
That is not to suggest that Villeneuve’sDuneshould have been a single motion-picture show - his two - part partitioning solves many more adaptational problem than it creates . But forPart 2to accomplish its full potential , there must be something to compensate for Leto and Isaac ’s inability to provide that contrast , and the choice were circumscribed . Indeed , the most important addition to theDune 2cast , Austin Butler as nega - Paul Feyd - Rautha Harkonnen , adds weight unit to the other side of the scale leaf .
Lady Jessica , without Leto ’s influence and after ingest the Water of Life , losesher man . The inner conflict between familial love and Bene Gesserit duty that Rebecca Ferguson had play inPart 1is replaced with a sinister conviction , forecast a like change in Paul . The Fremen , as a unit , must grow into a fanatical embrace of Muad’Dib as their promised savior . Gurney Halleck , reunited with his liege lord , is committed to restoring House Atreides to glory . The Emperor and Princess Irulan may recoil from Paul in repulsion , but we ’re barely attached to their perspective .
Chani is the only real solution , and the arranger change her to suit the new role . Already leery of her people ’s spiritual teachings , Zendaya ’s Fremen warrior perceives the film ’s events with a critical optic . She comes to love Paul , deep . She sees his sincere resistance to the destiny he has been promised , and believes in his desire to help fight Arrakis ' oppressors . Their bond is built on the premise of their being equals , and like Leto , she would not condemn Paul to a lifepath he does n’t want .
Dune: Part Two continues the epic saga of Paul Atreides as he allies with Chani and the Fremen. Pursuing retribution for his family’s devastation, Paul grapples with a significant decision impacting his personal desires and the universe’s future, attempting to avert a dire destiny that only he anticipates.
It confinesDune : Part 2to a pretty rigid timeline . As a result , Chani can not quite live the full purpose see for her .
Then she take in as , after outlast the Water of Life and achieving full prescience , he places himself above everyone . The sudden , rushed quality to Paul ’s final - act number has been a point of literary criticism for some , as has Chalamet ’s execution of it , but I see both as critical parts of the movie ’s success . There is a desire , having followed Paul all this time , to cheer as he leads the Fremen to triumph . But the abruptness in the filmmaking gash this with a sense of uneasiness . Like Chani , we are destabilized by the change we see in our hoagie .
Dune 2 ’s endingmakes clean that Chani is Villeneuve ’s intended counterpoint , and in expressing the taradiddle ’s most essential mind , she functions perfectly . ButZendaya ’s character can not be the easy human comportment that Isaac ’s was . She is hardened and cynical , and her kinship with Paul is young . She can see him for who he is and fully hold on the horror and betrayal of his rise to world power . But in a movie with many moving part , she lacks the prison term to amply embody the alternative way ahead that would lend grain to how we find about who her beloved becomes instead .
How To Compensate For Leto Without Disrupting Dune 2’s New Timeline
Alia Is A Pandora’s Box Villeneuve Is Determined Not To Open
But why does n’t Chani have the time?In the book , she and Paul have class together , not calendar month . They have a Word , who dies when the Emperor ’s Sardaukar attack a sietch ( another likely emotional lever ) . The changes to Chani ’s character mapped along this timeline could still have worked thematically , and would only have change their relationship on a dramatic level .
Book - to - film version often distill timelines for storytelling gismo , butDune 2had a more pressing reason than most : Alia Atreides . The daughter of Leto and Jessica , who feel the burden of the Water of Life before she is born , is a pocket-size minor by the time of the last battle in the novel . She is born with the full cognizance of an grownup Bene Gesserit and the psychical powerfulness of a Reverend Mother . She is , in other words , a nightmare for this establish , tactile cinematic rendition .
Villeneuve ’s solution , to keep Alia unborn and give her a phonation through Jessica , is graceful . We can believe the supernatural world of her existence without have to grease one’s palms into a nestling - as - adult public presentation , or whatever effects work would have been required to work her to forcible living . It also forces Jessica to vagabond the halls whisper like a madwoman , a delightfully unsettling touch .
A grown - up rendering of Alia is played by Anya Taylor - Joy in a sight of Paul ’s inDune : Part 2 . Her casting was kept occult until the motion-picture show ’s premiere .
However , it confinesDune : Part 2to a pretty strict timeline . As a answer , Chani can not quite inhabit the full purpose envisioned for her . If the film maker were forced into a barter - off , they made the right call . Alia ’s presence would have drastically tilt the tone the movie goes for , and the worked up contouring of a more highly-developed relationship between Paul and Chani might have been irrelevant .
Butif they could not havelivedthat reality , we could still haveseenit . Paul ’s visions are an significant stylistic motif in bothDunemovies , and they do not always come true . At the same metre as he sees his mother leading him into the desert and to a horrific holy war , he could also have see another elbow room forward . Show us what a aliveness with Chani could have been , Logos and all , had Paul been able to reject the course put down out for him .
Paul Atreides has many dreams and imagination of the hereafter in Dune : Part Two , render teases of case that will or could happen to the cosmos .
It seems mere , butI conceive this one accession would have been transformational . Not only would it have yield their romance the illusion of great depth than they had the way to rise , but we would have a clear understanding ( and attachment to ) what could have been . To know that Paul , too , had examine it , butchosedomination of his enemies anyway would have been heartbreaking . It would add spectacular weight to his cable about see all the possible future , and to his announcement of love at the moment of betrayal .
It would also have rime with the firstDune . Both movies , butPart 2especially , are fill up with echo ; they are central to the mythic weight Villeneuve reach . The first film builds to its climax by show us visions of Paul and a mysterious Fremen friend , Jamis , who kindly teach him the fashion of the desert . When they at long last meet , he is far from friendly - it turns out that Paul is required to kill him to earn his property .
Dune : Part 1 ’s endingis proof that visions can be used to inject a scene with worked up weight , and it would have felt entirely innate to see them deployed in the same manner for Chani . Without that one change , Dune 2is a singular achievement in epic filmmaking , and it has surely take in a place in the sci - fi movie pantheon . I can already feel it becoming a personal favorite I will revisit for year to come . But with it , I recollect it would have been perfect .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
Dune : Part Two continues the epic saga of Paul Atreides as he allies with Chani and the Fremen . Pursuing retribution for his class ’s devastation , Paul grapples with a significant decision impacting his personal desires and the macrocosm ’s future , attempting to avert a terrible fortune that only he anticipate .
