One Piece (Live-Action)
Summary
Spoiler Warning : This article contains spoiler for One Piece and Avatar : The Last Airbender .
One PieceandAvatar : The Last Airbenderhave been two of Netflix ’s most successful lively - natural process anime adaptation , but when it come in to which show is superior , there are a number of factors to see . WhileOne Piece ’s first time of year was successful enough to ensure asecond season ofOne Piecewill collide with the small CRT screen again , Avatar : The Last Airbenderwill also have a 2nd time of year , keep abreast its successful unrecorded - legal action first appearance . However , based on both show ' pacing , rendering of their respective characters , and innovative handling of their well - established lore , one show is a unmortgaged winner over the other .
Much ofOne Piece ’s praise is take aim at Netflix ’s handling of the first few arcs in the beloved manga / Zanzibar copal serial , and the way in whichAvatar : The Last Airbendersuccessfully blends the hard - hitting warlike arts with the series ' whimsical traditional knowledge also makes it one of the better unrecorded - activity adaptations in late memory . WhileOne PieceandAvatar : The Last Airbenderboth welfare from the various ways in which they adhere to their source fabric and deviate from it , both show do certain things exceptionally well , and there are other things that one show does easily than the other .
One Piece season 1 has pass on more deepness to small characters . Doing so again for a raw character in time of year 2 will make their floor even more tragic .
One Piece & Avatar: The Last Airbender Both Nailed Their Castings
The lead and supporting characters' casting greatly increases audience engagement.
One Piece ’s casting not only works because of the worker ' strong resemblance to their characters , but it also works because of their power to embody their essence almost whole despite the first season having to condense a lot of key information . AlthoughUsopp and Sanji did n’t obtain as much developmentas the residuum of the Straw Hat Pirates , the overall chemical science share between the protagonists more than made up for any other misgivings . Furthermore , in the case of small characters like Zeff and Ruina , One Piecedoes a with child task giving them stronger characterizations than in the source material .
WhileAvatar : The Last Airbendermakes changes to sealed characters that do n’t work , it also improves other authoritative characters in a major means . Fire Lord Ozai is given more depth inAvatar : The Last Airbender , which importantly improves his character from a writing perspective , since he was pretty flat in the beginning material . Daniel Dae Kim ’s performance as the restrain rule also gives Fire Lord Ozai enough charisma for his co - hotshot , both ally and foe , to bounce off of in piquant way . In addition to each show ’s splendid cast , they both pace the action very well .
One Piece & Avatar: The Last Airbender Both Had Good Pacing
Both shows have a different yet successful approach to their pacing.
One Piececovers the main and a few minor consequence from the Romance Dawn Arc through the Arlong Park Arc with a flourish that satisfies the expectations of viewers familiar with the source material , while also providing engage entertainment for newfangled TV audience . As demonstrated by thelive - actionYuYu Hakusho ’s poor tempo , a live - activity adaptation can stick out staggeringly if the fundamental events are n’t evolve properly . One Piecelargely solves the tempo issue by expend as much metre with multiple character and locations , effectively fill out its roughly sixty - min - per - sequence runtime .
One Piececovers the chief and a few minor events from the Romance Dawn Arc through the Arlong Park Arc with a tucket that satisfies the prospect of viewers intimate with the source material , while also providing rent amusement for newer viewers .
Although a coarse criticism among critics regardingAvatar : The Last Airbendercenters around the show ’s handling of the animated series ' first season , it still succeeds in endear the central characters to viewers . The originalAvatar : The Last Airbender ’s first season consist of twenty episode , but the Netflix version only has eight . Nevertheless , viewers get a clear sense of who Aang , Fire Lord Ozai , and the rest of the major characters are while delivering a satisfying level of worldbuilding via their interactions . WhileAvatar : The Last Airbenderhas a decent amount of content to cover , One Piecehas even more .
It Makes More Sense For One Piece Live-Action To Exist Than Avatar: The Last Airbender
One Piece has more material to adapt than Avatar: The Last Airbender.
A live - military action adaptation ofOne Piecemakes sentiency because the denseness of its germ material could raise a small too daunting for newcomers to in good order settle in to . With the live - action adaption ’s advance to condensing central information into a more palatable form , it provides an easy way for witness to engage with the textile . what is more , the in general positively charged reception of the adjustment make it possible for new audiences to go back and give the gum anime a luck if they themselves revalue the try made by the springy - activeness adaptation ’s interpretation of events .
Avatar : The Last Airbenderis much shorter by comparison , which raises concern about why a resilient - action at law adaption is on Netflix . The level of character ontogenesis , relatable characters , well - write dramatic play , and engaging battle all contributed toAvatar : The Last Airbenderdeveloping the reputation as thebest Nickelodeon show of the 2000s . WhileOne Piecehas a similar reputation in the anime and manga worlds , the sheer amount of textile thatOne Piececould adapt and reinterpret is compelling in its own right . Although both Netflix show are good , One Pieceexcels in one areaAvatar : The Last Airbenderfails .
TheOne Pieceanime currently has 1096 episodes , and the manga currently model at 1,015 chapters . embodiment : The Last Airbenderhas sixty - one episode .
Netflix ’s interpretation of Avatar : The Last Airbender time of year 1 fixes arguably the big mistake of M. Night Shyamalan ’s 2010 movie adjustment .
One Piece Made Fewer Major Changes To The Source Material
A common complaint regarding Avatar: The Last Airbender is its handling of certain characters and moments.
One Piecedoes make change to the beginning material , such as the introduction of sealed characters , but it largely remain close to the early portion of its informant material . embodiment : The Last Airbender , on the other handwriting , takes many impropriety with its source fabric that were n’t viewed too favorably by critic and viewers familiar with the reanimate serial publication . InAvatar : The Last Airbender , all three seasons of the series are divided into book : water , earth , and fire , and they thematically influence the storytelling as much as determine the standard atmosphere and setting of events for the military action .
Avatar : The Last Airbendermakes the curious decision to skip through key consequence that were crucial to not only make grow the original series ' human race and characters , but also to endear the character to its target audience . Another affair thatOne Piecedoes well is handle the optimistic tone of its source material while also check that its more ripe glide slope to certain moments all go . WhileAvatar : The Last Airbender ’s granulose tone is challenging , it never quite matches the constitute look of the original serial publication . As such , Avatar : The Last Airbendercomes up short by comparison toOne Piece .
InAvatar : The Last Airbender , all three seasons of the series are divided into books : water system , earth , and firing , and they thematically tempt the storytelling as much as determine the atmosphere and setting of issue for the action .
One Piece Season 1 Was Better Than Avatar: The Last Airbender Season 1 Overall
One Piece’s Rotten Tomatoes score is 85% whereas Avatar: The Last Airbender’s is 59%.
One Piece ’s treatment of the part , key story moments , special effects , and faithfulness to its author material all contribute to the show ’s better carrying into action with audiences and critics thanAvatar : The Last Airbender . Even though viewers did n’t get to see each appendage of the Straw Hat Pirates unite the Going Merry in the first season , One Piece ’s coming to how it handles the earlier moments work on in a more condensed formatting . Additionally , One Pieceseason 2 will inaugurate the remaining Straw Hat Piratesand some of the series ' mortal enemies , which only increases the anticipation .
One Piece ’s handling of the character , key story moments , special effects , and fidelity to its seed fabric all contribute to the show ’s better performance with audiences and critics thanAvatar : The Last Airbender .
embodiment : The Last Airbenderdoes many thing right , such as be sick each of its case appropriately and display fantabulous fight stage dancing . However , it hurt from the condensed approach to storytelling , as viewers do n’t get enough of the necessary context to fully betroth with each character or the world . embodiment : The Last Airbender ’s second seasonwill provide an splendid chance for Netflix to learn from the shortcomings of the first time of year and ameliorate upon them . Despite the differences in percept , One PieceandAvatar : The Last Airbenderare objectively great for the future of live - natural process adaptation .
